From first delivery to well-founded quality decision
During the development of a new electric excavator, one question was central: does the coating quality of externally produced steel components meet the requirements for durability and corrosion resistance?
With the first delivery of a boom sub-component as a critical “thermometer” for future series orders, the need arose for an objective and practically oriented validation of the coating system. Due to limited product specifications and short lead times, the challenge lay not only in conducting tests, but above all in determining which tests are essential to quickly arrive at reliable insights.
From complex component to practical test plan

The main components of the boom are large and difficult to handle. Representative, more manageable parts were therefore selected, on which the coating build-up and process quality are comparable to the end product.
Based on the available process information, a pragmatic yet effective test plan was drawn up. The focus was on one central goal: exposing potential weak points in the coating system under accelerated corrosion conditions.
Comparative salt spray test as the core of the validation
To make a clear and objective comparison between two samples, an accelerated corrosion test in accordance with ISO 9227 was selected.
The test setup consisted of:
- Test duration: 720 hours of salt spray exposure
- Mechanical damage: scratch of 10 cm long and 1 mm wide
- Measurement intervals: 240, 480 and 720 hours
- Assessment criteria: visual corrosion formation, blistering, defects along edges and corners, and degree of delamination from the scratch (after 720 hours)

This approach not only simulates prolonged exposure to an aggressive environment, but also tests how the coating system responds to damage — a realistic scenario in the day-to-day use of earthmoving machinery.
Objective insights into coating performance
The combination of controlled damage and prolonged salt spray exposure provides a clear picture of:
- The adhesion of the coating system under corrosive load
- The resistance to undercutting corrosion from damage points
- The susceptibility of critical zones such as edges and corners
- The consistency between different supplier samples
These insights make it possible not only to reveal differences, but also to ask targeted questions to the supplier and coating supplier — for example regarding process control, layer build-up and edge pre-treatment.
From test results to decision-making
The tests carried out provide a solid basis for a well-founded decision on whether or not to scale up to larger orders.
Rather than relying on specifications or assumptions, this approach offers:
- Directly comparable data between samples
- Insight into long-term risks
- Concrete starting points for quality improvement
This not only validates the quality of this specific component, but also establishes a reproducible method for future supplier assessments.
Practical, fast and targeted
This case demonstrates that an effective quality validation is possible even with limited specifications and time, provided the right choices are made in test strategy.
By focusing on the most critical failure mechanisms and using standardised test methods, clarity about what holds up in practice is quickly achieved — an approach that is widely applicable to other components, suppliers and development projects within the manufacturing industry.
Staad
Coating quality validation for electric excavator components.